Listen to this resource
0:00 / 0:00

Lament and Emotional Honesty Tracker

The Bible Gives You Permission to Feel What You Actually Feel

Lament is one of the most significant and most neglected practices in the Christian life. More than a third of the Psalms are laments: raw, honest cries of pain, anger, confusion, and grief directed straight at God without resolution or forced resolution. The book of Lamentations sits in the canon as an entire book of unresolved grief. Job argues with God for chapters. Jeremiah curses the day of his birth. The Biblical tradition does not ask suffering people to pretend. It provides them a language for bringing what is real directly into God's presence.

This tracker assesses ten dimensions of lament and emotional honesty, including the ability to name and feel difficult emotions rather than suppressing or spiritualizing them, the capacity to bring grief, anger, confusion, and despair honestly before God, the freedom to sit with unresolved pain rather than forcing premature comfort, and the willingness to engage the parts of Scripture that validate honest emotional struggle rather than only the parts that comfort. Complete it on your own and use it as a starting point for exploring how honestly your emotional life is being lived before God and before others.

References: Brueggemann, W. (1984). The message of the Psalms. Augsburg. | Card, M. (2005). A sacred sorrow. NavPress.

Tap-Friendly Self-Assessment

Rate each statement from 1 to 5 for this week, where 1 means “not at all true of me” and 5 means “very true of me.”

1. I am able to name what I am actually feeling this week, including difficult emotions, rather than staying at the surface or defaulting to 'I'm fine.'
2. I am able to feel my grief, anger, fear, or sadness rather than managing, suppressing, or spiritualizing it away.
3. I have brought at least one painful or difficult emotion honestly before God in prayer this week, not filtered or dressed up but as it actually is.
4. I am able to sit with pain or unresolved grief without immediately reaching for a Scripture verse or spiritual explanation to make it feel better faster.
5. I feel that my emotional experiences, including the painful ones, are acceptable before God rather than things I must hide or fix before I can approach Him.
6. When I am angry (including at God, at others, or at my circumstances), I am able to acknowledge that anger honestly rather than suppressing it or feeling ashamed of it.
7. I engage with the lament Psalms and other honest Biblical expressions of suffering as relevant to my own experience, not merely as historical texts.
8. I have been honest with at least one trusted person this week about how I am actually doing emotionally, not the version I think they want to hear.
9. I am able to grieve real losses, including losses others may not recognize or take seriously, without minimizing or rushing past them.
10. I trust that God can receive the full weight of my emotional reality (including darkness, confusion, and anger) without withdrawing from me.

Scoring and Reflection Guide

42–50Lament is being practiced and emotional honesty is present: you are able to name, feel, and bring your actual emotional experience to God and to trusted others without significant suppression or performance. This is a profound spiritual and emotional capacity. Take time to explore what has made this level of honesty possible and where, if anywhere, emotional avoidance still shows up.
31–41Emotional honesty is partial and growing: you are able to access and express some difficult emotions while others remain suppressed, spiritualized, or avoided. Take time to identify which specific emotions are most difficult to bring honestly before God or to name with others, and what the barrier is: shame, fear of loss of control, theological misunderstanding, or the absence of safe relationships.
19–30Significant emotional suppression may be present across multiple dimensions: grief, anger, fear, or confusion are being managed, minimized, or spiritualized rather than honestly felt and expressed. This pattern often has both emotional and theological roots. Take time to explore what has taught you that your emotional reality is not safe to bring before God or to share with others.
10–18The emotional life appears largely closed or hidden: difficult emotions are not being named, felt, brought to God, or shared with trusted others. This level of emotional suppression is significant and can take a real toll over time. Treat this as a safe place to begin exploring what is being held inside, not to produce immediate emotional release but to begin opening the conversation about what has made honesty feel so unsafe.

Honest Grief Before God Is Not the Absence of Faith; It Is Its Exercise

The church has often communicated, explicitly or by silence, that negative emotions are spiritually dangerous. That grief means insufficient trust. That anger at God is sin.

That the appropriate Christian response to suffering is immediate, visible peace. The Psalms say something completely different. They say: bring it all.

Bring the darkness, the rage, the confusion, the sense of abandonment. Bring Psalm 88, which ends without resolution. Bring the cry of desolation from the cross.

The God who inspired these texts is not surprised or threatened by honest human pain. Suppressing what is true does not produce spiritual health. It produces a gap between the inner life and the presented life that eventually widens into something much harder to close.

The practice of lament (bringing the full weight of what is real directly into God's presence) is not a sign of weak faith. It is the exercise of the faith that trusts God enough to be completely honest with Him. If you meet with a pastor or counselor, bring your responses, especially the items that were hardest to answer honestly.

Those are the places where the most important pastoral work is waiting.

Prefer a printable copy? Download “Lament and Emotional Honesty Tracker” as a PDF
Back to Serious Mental Health
Christian Care ResourcesLament and Emotional Honesty Tracker